Maple Leafs reputation depends on John Tavares management – Hockey Writers – Toronto Maple Leafs

Last Wednesday, the Toronto Maple Leafs officially named Auston Matthews as the 26th captain in franchise history, succeeding John Tavares for the 2024-25 NHL season. Tavares has been captain since 2019, and although many saw this change coming, it raises important questions about his future with the club. How the Maple Leafs choose to handle Tavares this season will reveal a lot about the organization and could have lasting implications throughout the NHL.

The Leadership Revolution: What it means for Tavares

When a captain is transferred in the NHL, it usually indicates a change in the direction of the team or the departure of the outgoing captain. With Matthews now wearing the “C,” some analysts and fans have speculated that Tavares’ time in Toronto may be coming to an end. After all, he will be 34 years old at the start of the season, and some say his production is declining. However, those who suggest that Tavares should be removed miss a critical aspect of his role on the team.

Related: Former Leafs defenseman Jake Gardiner: Where is he now?

The idea that Tavares might seek a big payday elsewhere is absurd. He chose to come home to Toronto in 2018 and has been an example of leadership and professionalism ever since. Tavares handed over the captaincy to Matthews, showing his commitment to the team’s success in his honor. If he is willing to give up something as important as the captain, it is clear that he would agree to let go of the big money to sign an agreement to stay with his home team.

Three Reasons The Maple Leaf Should Appreciate Tavares

There are at least three reasons why the Maple Leafs should treat Tavares well. First, you have shown honesty and leadership. His decision to step down as captain is a testament to his character. His leadership extends beyond the ice, touches the younger players and strengthens the team’s culture. Rewarding him with a new contract will show that the Maple Leafs value selfless leadership, setting an example for the entire organization.

Second, while his production will decline as he gets older, he remains a consistent scorer. He may not be the elite player he once was, but he’s reliably putting up good numbers. He averages 70 points per season and pumps less than 30 goals, 29 last season. His offensive production is still strong. He is still the NHL leader in faceoff percentage. His experience and hockey IQ are invaluable, and he is fearless in front of the net. Keeping him on the roster ensures that the team keeps a player.

Related: Matthews and Laine: Comparing Careers as Rivalry Resurfaces

Third, he is a role model for building team chemistry and culture. Tavares’ professionalism and dedication have been a stabilizing force for the Maple Leafs. He opens his home for young players who need a place to stay temporarily. His presence in the locker room and on the bench helps shape the team’s identity. Ensuring that he stays will keep the team’s culture going and ensure that the young players have a mentor who shows what it means to wear the Blue & White jersey.

Consequences of Letting Tavares Go

But there is also a downside that the Maple Leafs wish to avoid. The franchise would be making a huge mistake if they didn’t recognize Tavares’ importance to the team. Releasing him would greatly affect their reputation within the NHL, and the negative optics would be dangerous.

First, players often want to play with organizations that value honesty and integrity. If the Maple Leafs were to release Tavares after he steps down as captain and re-signs a team-friendly contract (which I think he will), it would be seen as a lack of appreciation for his dedication. Some players may see this as a sign that the team is prioritizing short-term gains over long-term relationships, making them wary of committing to Toronto.

When free agents consider joining a team, they analyze the contract, its culture, and the way it treats its players. If the Maple Leafs were seen as an organization that quickly dumped reliable veterans like Tavares, it would prevent top talent from signing in Toronto. Players may avoid an organization that focuses more on the business side of hockey than building strong, personal relationships.

While hockey is undeniably a business, players value management as more than just a commodity. If the franchise were to move on from Tavares without acknowledging his sacrifice, it would reinforce the reputation that the organization is less focused on the player. It will cease to be a magnet for Toronto-area players who would like to end their playing careers at home.

Related: Leafs Captain Maple Will Force Auston Matthews To Change

The way the team treats Tavares also affects the players closer to home, who are already on the roster. How managers treat veterans and their leaders will have a major impact on morale. If Tavares were to be released without a contract consideration, other players may question their value to the organization. This may affect team cohesion and performance. Could the other players also start to believe that the writing was on the wall for them, too?

Long-term trust issues may arise. Players who see the way Tavares is treated may wonder if they too can be let go if their performance declines, no matter how loyal they are to the team. This can create a culture of low self-esteem, where players feel they have to look out for themselves rather than fully commit to the long-term success of the team. They may decide to scramble while they can before they’re forced to go with whatever version of the NHL draft it might be.

The Maple Leafs Will Do Well To Treat Tavares Like Royalty

The bottom line is that while the Maple Leafs must make strategic decisions about their roster, how they handle Tavares will say a lot about the organization’s values. By treating Tavares with the respect he deserves and recognizing his contributions, they can maintain a reputation as a player-friendly organization that values ​​loyalty. On the other hand, letting him go without attention could hurt the team’s ability to attract and retain top talent in the future, creating negative optics for the rest of the league.

Related: Maple Leafs’ Cowan Expectations Should Be Reasonable in Pursuit of Roster Spot

The best outcome would be to install Tavares as the Maple Leafs center. He re-signed him to a club friendly contract and allowed him to retire in a Blue and White uniform. Then, when he retires, follow him with Darryl Sittler, Mats Sundin, and other icons of Maple Leafs history. Treat him like royalty—both now and after retirement.

Tavares’ determination to put the team first is exactly the character this franchise needs. Dismissing him or treating him with anything less than the utmost respect is not just a disagreement; the future of the group is in danger. Tavares’ legacy in Toronto should be celebrated, not questioned, and his continued presence on the roster will strengthen the team’s chances of success.